Page 1 of 2
Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment!
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:09 pm
by GabrielleFandomGirl
Everybody, I think that a lot of fans have a tendency, to be unkind in posts about actors. I mean, can Kristina Puccelli help it, if members of the true Emily haters club, Or of the Emily stinks klub, don't like her voice? No. Can Katie Leigh help it, if one fan unkindly thinks that if she would get voted best aio actress of the year, if she had a single word in an episode. ( I actually read a post last week that said that.) No, she can't. Nobody has the right to say that a hardworking actor, who is doing their job to the best of their ability, stinks, or is hated. Its mean. Unkind. Just flat out horrible. If agree or disagree, please post and reply. This is a new klub. The I will say what i want to say in a kind way klub. thanks. p.s. I'm not 8. Im over the age.
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:14 pm
by Whittifer
Ok, I like Emily's voice. I don't hate that actress I hate Emily. The character.
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:16 pm
by GabrielleFandomGirl
Hey.
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:18 pm
by Whittifer
What's hey about? Sorry, if that sounded mean. I just don't like people saying I'm insulting the actress.
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:20 pm
by GabrielleFandomGirl
Oh, I was just saying hi, and I wasn't talking about you specifically, just other posts in general.
Whittifer how old are you? Just curious.
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:22 pm
by Whittifer
Hey, right back. Thanks, I thought you were saying hey to me like I said something mean.
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:24 pm
by Tea Ess
I suggest you read the first page of each club. They have very noble intentions and beginnings.
No one is angry at the actors. Some of them simply don't fit the part, and there are people who say so unabashedly. When we say we hate Emily, there are several distinctions:
We do not dislike the actor, just the character.
Many do not even hate Emily herself, just the way she is used.
We like to have a bit of fun once in a while, and having a mock Emily war helps us do this.
I know that many of us have grown closer through the Emily war, and we all have gotten to know each other better. No one tries to be mean. Sometimes we all come across as such, but that is not our intent.
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:25 pm
by GabrielleFandomGirl
Oh and by the way, I was talking about a post that one kid accually posted about Katie Leigh. I just created this to say that i have met these people, and there really great , they don't deserve to be bullied by some fans. I'm so sorry.
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:27 pm
by Whittifer
Ok. When you made this topic it made me feel bad.
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:29 pm
by Tea Ess
I agree. Each and every one of the actors is amazing, we shouldn't critize them in a rude way. You are right in that regard. You don't have to be sorry. It's still a good topic. I just wanted you to understand that we aren't trying to be mean.
P.S. Whittifer told me to say goodbye for her. She has to leave.
P.P.S. The one other thing is that Pound Foolish, the maker of the first Emily club, started it to stir up a little controversy and engage in a mock battle. He almost intended it as a joke. all the other Emily clubs were made to battle his.
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:32 pm
by GabrielleFandomGirl
I am glad of no hard feelings. Hey, let s head to miny chat for a minute, and talk! Youll find me there. maybe we can get some others to post on this topic.
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:40 pm
by Tea Ess
Alright. Good.
If it helps, most of the great members here had controversial beginnings and had to apologize or smooth things over. An exception to this would be The Old Judge, who manages to post his opinion clearly without offending anyone, and the girls that could be twins. Besides that, most of us have had a rough start.
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 10:40 pm
by GabrielleFandomGirl
I wasn't talking really, about anybody in spesific, but some kids are mean.
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 11:16 pm
by Doll
In regards to this, I would like to refer you to a post made by PF after a bit of controversy:
Pound Foolish wrote:Everyone who was participating in the insults did understand it was all in fun, Mr. Thinker. The trouble comes when you assume everyone else is sensitive. When Mr. Thinker yells a playful insult, it's a license for anyone to join in. But we all actually like each other, and don't mean a word we say, so nobody's hurt, as there's no reason to be.
Some of my best friends insult me all the time because we LIKE each other, and we KNOW we do, so it doesn't matter how much we insult each other. We'd never act that way around someone we weren't good friends with, but since we are, we know it's really just our way of showing each other we're close. They didn't insult me when they didn't know and like me well. If they were to stop insulting me, I'd be worried they didn't like me anymore!
There's a serious side to debating Emily, where TS, Meltsner Girl, Mr. Thinker, and I, all contemplate the problems and religious implications of her character, in the debating Emily topic, mostly. Then there's the downright absurd side of how much we disagree about this, and the fun of forming our little Emily-cyber-political-parties. That's the part I so often mess around with with good ol' Suzy. And that, as I say, is what's going on here.
So, those who playfully insult are fine with it. You DON'T like it, and we've never insulted you, because we know you would be bothered. That's the way this works. But don't expect everyone else to feel the way the way you do. I hope none of this offends you, I'm just trying to explain matters to you to prevent future hurt and worry for you.
He made this post to reply to me, but I thought it explained some of the war.
(BTW, T.S. who are the not-but-could-be twins?)
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Mon Oct 01, 2012 5:39 pm
by Whittifer
Ya, who are they? I was wondering the same thing.
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Mon Oct 01, 2012 7:08 pm
by Tea Ess
There are several girls here that are very similar in personality, including gabby, EugeneforPresident, and possibly a couple of the newer people I don't know yet. You, God's girl, and EugeneforPresident are also rather similar, except she is younger.
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Mon Oct 01, 2012 7:21 pm
by Whittifer
I'm unique! Let's get back on topic. I have never made a mean ACTOR comment. I might have made a mean character comment, but never an actor.
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Mon Oct 01, 2012 7:25 pm
by Tea Ess
Yeah. I feel pretty strongly about a few of the characters, but I rarely find fault with the actors. Even when I do, I try to be polite; they are people, but the characters are not.
I also think that harsh critisism should be balanced with deserved praise. I try to find good things about characters (Blackgaard, Lucy, etc.) along with bad things about other characters (Emily, Wooton, etc.).
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Mon Oct 01, 2012 7:27 pm
by Whittifer
Ya, I'd never say Katie Leigh is ugly or Andre Stojka is old.
Re: Calling all fans who have ever made a mean actor comment
Posted: Mon Oct 01, 2012 7:32 pm
by GabrielleFandomGirl
I agree, but i have seen a post, where i a fan said, i quote, " if katie leigh had but one grunt on an episode fans would vote her actress of the album." See? some fans are negative.