The Soda Shop Message Boards

Is called on in class good, or bad?

It was awesome!! I loved the history lesson, and the fact that Trent is related to the McAlisters.

But it's still not better than The Blackguaard and Novacom Saga combined?

That would have to be an AMAZING episode, like Someone To Watch Over Me.

You think Someone to Watch Over Me is better than the Novacom and Blackguaard Sagas combined? Wow, you must really like it! I really like it too, but I wouldn't go that far...

Come on, it's awesome!!!

The Old Judge wrote:Come on, it's awesome!!!

I agree. 8-) I think The Time Has Come is better than The Blackguaard and Novacom Sagas combined. (I don't count it as part of The Blackguaard Saga, even though other people might. The Darkness Before Dawn mini-series is ten episodes, not eleven! The Time Has Come is not affiliated much with Blackguaard!)

I LOVE it!!!

I do agree that the daydreaming gets annoying, but I like the history part a lot.

CreativeThinker101 wrote:But it's still not better than The Blackguaard and Novacom Saga combined?

No way. There is not a single episode that I would say this about. None.
It is a pretty good episode, but not my favorite.

Frankly, I don't like Called On In Class much. I voted (in my own poll) that I think Trent's dreaming seemed a little dumb. Sorry for all of you that really like it, but I just didn't love it too much. The Present Long Ago, in my opinion, was better. But, we all have those episodes that everyone hates and we really like. I actually enjoy most of the episodes in Album 51.

CreativeThinker101 wrote:But it's still not better than The Blackguaard and Novacom Saga combined?

Thats for sure.

Katerina Meltsner wrote:

CreativeThinker101 wrote:But it's still not better than The Blackguaard and Novacom Saga combined?

Thats for sure.

Oh, come on. Blackguaard and Novacom were horrible! LOL

I enjoyed it very much actually...

HannahJ. wrote:I enjoyed it very much actually...

Read The Odyssey Scoop review. If you like this episode, you'll hate Jacob forever for posting it.

I just wrote a review of Called On In Class on my blog! Check it out!

Called on in class is... a comedy. A comedy is completely reliant on taste, just how much non-subtle in-your-face-utter absurdity you can handle. I'm a sucker for children's in-your-face comedy, and enjoyed every minute. If someone doesn't like this episode, it's really not a quality problem, it's preferences.

a piece of junk

It's irritating. Not one of Bob Hoose's better episodes.

I liked it because it showed Trent's abundant imagination.

i did not like this episode, i mean come on really? yeah we're really gonna have the president listen to some 6th graders speech. NOT. i like imagination, i had quite the imagination when i was lil', i use to dream that Narnia was real and i would pretend that i lived there. but i never dreamed up stuff like the whole school would chase me,and that i would faint, or that the roof would cave in. what are we 3? i just dont like things like this.