Blackgaard's Revenge -- A hit or miss?

Grab your AIO albums, and find a table! What makes your favorite episode the best? Have an episode you really dislike? This is the place to review and discuss AIO episodes and albums.

Did you enjoy Blackgaard's Revenge?

Hit! - It was awesome, and I think that everyone should lift it up on a pedestal for everyone plus your grandma to see.
7
27%
Mediocre - It's pretty good -- but I don't really think it's one of my favorites.
15
58%
Miss! - I hat---uh, strongly dislike, it! It's unrealistic and Dr. Blackgaard shouldn't have come back anyway, so...yeah. Don't like it.
4
15%
 
Total votes: 26

User avatar
Bob
Caramel Crunch
Posts: 114
Joined: October 2016
Location: The Metroplex
Contact:

Re: Blackgaard's Revenge -- A hit or miss?

Post

Listening to it again some time back, I think it's a two-parter driven mainly by Earl Boen's acting ability. If it was any other villain it would have been a disaster, but with Blackgaard it becomes surprisingly compelling at parts.

The writing for the good guys and their acting are all relatively weak this episode, although I thought Paul Herlinger did a pretty good job in the climax.

There are a lot of cheesy things and weaknesses in the plot (the big one being, as someone pointed out in a post years back, that the analogy they're driving at falls flat because Whit didn't personally sacrifice anything), but one other part where I think they drop the ball at the end is when Connie asks something like "Is Blackgaard truly dead now". I think Whit commented on this earlier in the episode, but it was forgotten by the end: the real Dr. Blackgaard died years ago, at the time this episode is portraying. The virus might have something like his personality or memories but his soul is long gone.

That said, whenever Earl Boen is "on screen", the episode magically becomes interesting. I remember being appropriately scared when I was a kid listening to the Civil War scene at the beginning, and I think he did a good job in the climax as well.

Some people look at it as a lowlight in Odyssey history. They have some good points, but I'd urge them to look at the bright side -- they could have brought Blackgaard back to life and made DBD completely pointless. Instead of that, we got this. It's a very flawed two-parter but I think it's enjoyable if you make the effort.
A classic never goes out of style.
User avatar
Kungfunaomi
Cookies & Creme
Posts: 282
Joined: May 2017
Location: CONFIDENTIAL

Re: Blackgaard's Revenge -- A hit or miss?

Post

*Barfs*
I only listen to it to hear Earl Boen. Everything else was awful, in my opinion. The premise, especially.
User avatar
Conniekendall fan
Strawberry
Posts: 58
Joined: February 2018
Location: Stuck inside a bucket.
Contact:

Re: Blackgaard's Revenge -- A hit or miss?

Post

yeah i agree it wasn't the best even though i voted hit.
Constance Kendall
Post Reply