Monica Stone wrote: ↑
Mon Dec 28, 2020 4:25 pm
I thought this season was pretty solid! The first half of the year (excluding "Young Whit & the Revolutionary Secret") had my favourites and I thought they were really great. "Unsinkable, Parts 1-2" was very moving and excellently done. Kathy Buchanan shines with historical dramas. I thought the scenes with present-day Emily, Jason, and Whit paled in comparison to the flashbacks but were still solid. The scene where the Titanic sinks... was hauntingly & perfectly done. "Out of Her Element" was just a ton of fun and was pretty clever. "Young Whit & the Revolutionary Secret" was...thematically convoluted. It introduced themes and story points and muddled them IMO. "Bridget, Redefined" was yet another extremely well-written Perkins family episode and I loved
hearing more about Bridget and her struggles. "Cars, Trains & Motorcycles" is a new classic and a classic Connie/Eugene episode and high Whit...lol.
The second half of the episodes were much more hit or miss. I liked "Millstones" a whole lot...until Connie started acting uncharacteristically. Despite having minor gripes with it, "Badges of Honor" was good and enjoyable. "A Simple Reminder" was simple fun and I laughed at the jokes involving Wilson having a virus and struggling to manage technology. "The Martyr and the Rooster" was dark but it memorably used that darkness. And, to be perfectly honest, I didn't really enjoy the final two episodes "The Forever Gift" and "Teach a Man." I just had too many issues.
Overall, I think "Unsinkable, Part 2" was my favourite but there are many gems. I'm definitely looking forward to the 2021 episodes and I'm excited to see what's in store.
Wow, I never thought I'd say this but I agree almost 100% with a comment, and literally felt the same thing, and wrote it on my own website. The first half of the year was definitely awesome, and I agree Kathy Buchanan's writing for historical drama is AMAZING,. I didn't enjoy "Young Whit" because it wasn't super involving or entertaining, I like Millstones at first but upon several relistens have grown a distaste for it." Bridget, Redefined" was well done, and "Out of Her Element" and "Cars, Trains, and Motorcycles" were HILARIOUS, very different from Kathy Buchanan's comedic style, but still quite well done.
The second half was odd, I found "A Simple Reminder" quite odd, I thought the technology part was funny, but the rest was... painfully silly to say the least, and at the end basically says "There's no moral, but there is" cementing my thoughts that the episode was better off maybe not being made. "Teach a Man" and "The Forever Gift" were honestly, forgettable, I didn't love how the characters of Wooton, Penny, Jay, and Zoe were portrayed, and to be quite honest they weren't as funny or relatable as other episodes ex. "The Shame About Fame" and "All for the Guest" (coincidentally both Kathy Buchanan episodes), they were slightly above average episodes at best. "The Martyr and the Rooster" had an odd end and beginning, and the main story didn't compel me as much because of the similar voices and semi-interesting plot. I didn't love "Badges of Honor" the first time I heard it but I've grown to enjoy it. The majority of the last six are better upon a relisten, part of my dislike for them may have had to do with the first 6 setting the bar so high, but the stories were objectively not as good.
Overall a pretty good year for the club, in terms of production and writing quality there was a dip in originality and uniqueness from Season 6, but there were more episodes I liked, oddly enough. Props to the odyssey team on another good year of club episodes. Can't wait to hear more from Marshal, Kathy, and Bob (Smithouser) in the future!
Club Season 7 Ranked and Rated
- 1-2. Unsinkable, Pt.1-2: 97%
3. "Cars, Trains, and Motorcyles": 95%
4. "Out of Her Element"- 93%
5. "Bridget Redefined"- 90%
6. "Badges of Honor"- 88%
7. "Teach a Man"- 87%
8. "The Forever Gift"- 86%
9. "The Martyr and the Rooster"- 84%
10. "Millstones"- 80%
11. "Young Whit and the Revolutionary Secret"- 78%
12. "A Simple Reminder- 70%